Fictional worked exampleBOOK-218 · as of Nov 3

See what came back — and why.

An illustrative booking change, with fictional people, observations and results. Explore the findings, their evidence and the work still to do.

The issue · BOOK-218 · project Courtline

Members can cancel their own unpaid court bookings

Three sentences, four checks · staging.courtline.example · as Member A and Member B, your test accounts.

The answer · marks by date · human-verified

Cancellation passed. Immediate release is still unverified.

Cancellation passed. A fix improved slot availability, but immediate release is still unverified. Two other checks are unfinished. The table shows each result and its date.

CheckOct 28 · originalNov 3 · retestWho continuesEvidence
01
Own unpaid booking can be cancelled from My bookings

Works as the issue says: cancelled from My bookings as Member A, list and response watched.

Oct 28Passed
Nov 3not retested
Nothing open
02
A cancelled slot comes free for other members

Failed on Oct 28: the slot stayed taken after the cancellation. After your fix, on Nov 3, it was free a minute later and bookable — whether it comes free straight away is not yet shown.

Oct 28Failed · #4471
Nov 3Not verified · #4502 / #4503
Ours · nextObserve the release itself from the moment of a cancellation. No extra credits.
03
Someone else’s booking shows no Cancel action

Not yet checked. No observation of another member’s booking was recorded.

Oct 28Not verified
Nov 3not retested
Ours · nextEstablish a usable route with the permitted accounts and run the check. No extra credits.
04
A paid booking shows no Cancel action

Not yet checked: no paid booking existed, and the issue rules payments out.

Oct 28Not verified
Nov 3not retested
Needs from youA paid booking we may use — an existing one is enough; only if one had to be made, permission for one test payment.

Each result keeps its date. Not verified means there is not enough evidence for a verdict. Your team decides whether to release.

The evidence · five records for four checks

The records, observation by observation.

The original and the retest stay separate records. Each observation names who looked and when; opening one shows the screen or response behind it.

Check 02 · Oct 28Failed · #4471

A cancelled slot comes free for other members

Oct 28 · the original run

Given · Oct 28. Booking #4471 cancelled by its owner at 10:02 AM. Permissions that day: sign in and view as A or B; cancel bookings we create as Member A; no payments; your 9:55 AM answer — existing data only.
  1. 10:02 AM · as Member ABooking #4471 cancelled from My bookings — the condition this check starts from. Open that observation in record 01

Next on this check: the Nov 3 retest, a separate record →

What this record concludes

Failed · Oct 28

The slot stayed Unavailable to another member twenty minutes after the cancellation, and the response still named the cancelled booking as holder. Returned Oct 28, 10:31 AM, human-verified. The fix was yours to make; one retest of the same scope within 14 days is included.

12 min 47 s · Failed · returned 10:31 AM, human-verified
Who continues

Your fix, then the retest The fix was yours to make; the same-scope retest after it is a separate record, Nov 3.

Open an observation to see the screen or response behind it.

Deeper references

Questions, permissions and follow-through.

On the issue: the panel exchange and Jira notifications

The checks, the reports, and the question with your answer live in the Checktide panel on BOOK-218. Jira received three short notifications from Checktide about this change — not the only comments in the whole issue.

Checktide panel · question for check 03 · answered
CT
Checktide · Oct 28 · 9:48 AM · questionQuestion for check 03: may we create a booking as Member B? None owned by another member exists.
You
You · Oct 28 · 9:55 AM · recorded answerNot now. Use existing data only.

Answered on Oct 28 — a past exchange; nothing is waiting. Check 03’s current facts are in record 03.

Jira comments · notifications only
CT
Checktide · Oct 28 · 9:48 AMChecktide has a question about the verification you started. Answer it in the Checktide panel on this issue.
CT
Checktide · Oct 28 · 10:31 AMReport ready in the Checktide panel: 01 Passed · 02 Failed · 03 Not verified · 04 Not verified.
CT
Checktide · Nov 3 · 2:41 PMRetest report ready in the Checktide panel: 02 Not verified. 01, 03 and 04 were not retested and keep their Oct 28 marks.

Permissions, as they stood

Oct 27 · Initial permission: sign in and view as Member A or Member B; cancel bookings we create as Member A; no payments.

Oct 28 · 9:48 AM we asked whether we may create a booking as Member B for check 03; 9:55 AM you answered: “Not now. Use existing data only.”

Nov 2 · From the report, you widened it: create and cancel unpaid bookings as Member A or Member B; payments still not permitted.

What Not verified means here

Not verified means we could not yet conclude. Sometimes there are observations and partial evidence; sometimes a condition the check needs was not available, so the check itself was not completed. Either way the reason, the agreed scope, the next step and who carries it are stated — it is never a pass, and a later stage never upgrades an earlier mark.

Continuing responsibility

Ours, next, in the original scope: observe the release itself as Member B from the moment of a cancellation. Nothing is needed from you and no extra credits.

Ours, next, in the original scope: establish a usable route with the permitted accounts — the existing #4466 as Member B first; creating a booking as Member B, allowed since Nov 2, is an additional route — and run the check. Nothing is needed from you; no extra credits.

Needs from you: a paid booking in the environment that we may use — an existing one is enough. Only if one has to be made would we also need permission for one test payment.

Credits on this example

Oct 28: 12 min 47 s on check 02 and 3 min 05 s on check 01, at $0.30 a minute billed by the second. Nov 3: 9 min 12 s, no credits — a retest of the same scope after your fix; it reached no result, so the included retest was not used. Completing the original scope on 02 and 03 costs no extra credits.

Limits of this page

The dates and timings are illustrative, not a turnaround commitment. Exploring this example does not start a verification.